Behind the Prestige:
Are New IITs and IIMs Failing Students Beyond Academics?
🎓 The Illusion of Excellence
They made it. Cracking the IIT-JEE or CAT is no joke. It’s a dream nurtured by thousands, realized by a few. When you enter an IIT or IIM—whether old or new—you walk in with pride, high hopes, and the confidence that the best years of your life are about to begin.
But for students at many of India’s newer IITs and IIMs, that dream is increasingly meeting a frustrating reality: classrooms may be world-class, but everything outside them feels unfinished, underfunded, and unplanned.
🏏 Where’s the Playground?
You can’t talk about a fulfilling college life without talking about sports. From the adrenaline of football matches to the camaraderie of late-night badminton rallies, sports form an essential layer of student life.
Yet, in many newer campuses:
There’s no proper ground for outdoor sports.
Indoor sports facilities are cramped, missing, or “under development.”
Students often use public parks or rent facilities off-campus.
Professional coaching or student-athlete support? Almost non-existent.
In conversations across Reddit, InsideIIM, and student-led forums in 2024–25, frustration is evident. Students share stories of missing out on tournaments due to lack of practice space or giving up on fitness routines entirely due to poor infrastructure.
This is not just about missing a game—it’s about missing a lifestyle.
🧩 The Missing Puzzle: Mental and Emotional Well-being
Let’s call it what it is: college is stressful. Especially when you're in institutions where the academic bar is sky-high.
And yet, in many new IITs and IIMs:
No wellness centers
No professional counselors on campus
No recreation hubs to unwind
No safe, inclusive student zones
In 2025, as conversations around mental health and burnout become louder, these gaps are more than an inconvenience. They’re dangerous. Students are juggling academics, placements, competitions—and yet are left with no outlet to cope.
🏠 Hostels That Don’t Feel Like Home
The promise: safe, hygienic, comfortable living spaces that support learning and growth.
The reality in some newer campuses:
Temporary apartment-style buildings used as hostels
Shared rooms beyond planned capacity, Single Occupancy Rooms been Converted to Double Occupancy without proper storages and Table/Chairs
Water issues, electricity breakdowns, hygiene concerns
Hostels located far from campus, increasing commute time and safety concerns
Some campuses have improved over time, yes. But as more batches enter and academic operations scale, the hostel infrastructure often lags dangerously behind.
🎭 Campus Culture on Pause
The most transformative lessons aren’t always learned in classrooms.
Ask any alumni from older campuses and they’ll talk about:
Organizing cultural fests
Late-night club meetings
Building event startups from scratch
Performing on stage, losing debates, winning others
In newer campuses, these stories are harder to come by.
Why?
No dedicated cultural hall or auditorium
Committees/Clubs operate from hostels or book classrooms temporarily
Lack of funding or institutional support
Faculty bottlenecks in approving events
This creates a culture gap—where students are academically trained, but not culturally or socially evolved in the same way.
🎙️ Real Voices from the Ground
Here’s what students had to say in 2025 forums and anonymous interviews:
“I came here expecting I’d get to run a fest or at least attend one like I saw in videos. Instead, we couldn’t even get a mic system arranged without three layers of approval.”
— PGDM student, 2025
“There are days you just want to go to the ground and play. But there’s no ground. We sometimes use a road inside campus for football.”
— Engineering student, new IIT
— MBA student, new IIM
“We respect the professors and the curriculum. But the rest of the experience doesn’t feel IIM-standard.”
— MBA student, 2024/2025
These aren’t isolated sentiments—they echo across campuses, states, and programs.
📊 Snapshot: What’s Missing?
🧠 What Faculty Say (and Why Their Hands Are Tied)
It’s not that the faculty or administration is unaware.
Many professors—especially in leadership roles at new IITs/IIMs—have spoken candidly at events or interviews about the challenges of building a campus from scratch:
Delays in land acquisition
Red tape for infrastructure approvals
Budget allocation limits
Hiring bottlenecks for support staff
And still, they push to create academic excellence amidst limitations. But the fact remains: students feel the consequences directly.
💼 What Employers Notice
You might think recruiters don’t care about fest management or sports trophies.
Think again.
In 2025, companies prioritize teamwork, leadership, adaptability, and soft skills—all of which are developed outside the classroom:
Recruiters prefer candidates who’ve run large-scale events or led diverse teams.
Students from newer campuses sometimes lack those real-world team experiences.
Peer learning, a strong driver of interview performance, is stunted by weak campus culture.
Some HR managers have even started recommending gap-year projects or NGO volunteering to “balance” what the campus doesn’t provide.
🌍 Global Lens: How Top Institutions Do It
Take a glance at leading universities worldwide—Stanford, Oxford, or NUS. You’ll find:
Multiple student lounges
Professional-level sports facilities
24x7 counseling centers and quiet rooms
Student-run event budgets of tens of thousands of dollars
Architecturally inspiring recreational zones
Their philosophy? Academic stress must be matched with creative, cultural, and recreational breathing space.
If India wants to make IITs and IIMs globally competitive—not just in research but in experience—we need to invest in life outside the classroom too.
🔎 The Root Cause: Fast Expansion, Slow Infrastructure
India’s education policy encourages growth. But here’s what’s happening:
New campuses are launched within 1–2 years
First few batches begin studies in rented or temporary setups
Infrastructure takes 5–7 years to fully materialize
Meanwhile, student batches grow—and pressure mounts
This mismatch between student population and support infrastructure is at the heart of the problem.
🧭 The Road Ahead: How to Fix It
Fixing the gaps won’t be easy—but it’s not impossible.
What Institutes Can Do:
Build multi-purpose common areas quickly (even temporary ones)
Partner with local sports/cultural centers
Create "Student Experience Offices" with dedicated resources
Make sure student feedback loops influence infrastructure planning
Launch funded leadership programs that simulate event/project management
What MHRD/UGC Can Enable:
Require minimum recreational & hostel benchmarks before expanding intake
Offer special grants for wellness and student experience
Mandate student facility audits every 2 years for new institutes
Provide fast-track construction approvals through a digital single window
💬 Final Thoughts: A Campus is More Than Classrooms
You can have a brilliant syllabus, PhD-level professors, and top recruiters—but if a student leaves your campus exhausted, uninspired, or unconnected, something is deeply wrong.
The IITs and IIMs—especially the newer ones—have the potential to lead a new wave of higher education in India. But it won’t happen through academics alone.
It’ll happen when:
Every hostel feels like a second home
Every student has access to play, to perform, to lead
Fests run without red tape
Late-night laughter echoes in common rooms
And alumni remember not just what they studied, but who they became
Because education isn’t just a degree—it’s a life lived fully.
Build campuses that honor that.
No comments:
Post a Comment